Lesson 3 of 9 · How a deal gets done
What is an investment thesis
6 min read · Updated Nov 16, 2026
The short answer
An investment thesis is a short written statement of what kind of company you want to buy, why that kind of company should earn a good return and what would make you say no. It turns a view of an industry into criteria specific enough to search, score and reject companies with.
By the end of this lesson you will be able to:
- Define an investment thesis and name its parts
- Separate the criteria that can be searched from the judgments that are scored
- Test a thesis against price, competing buyers and the supply of companies
A thesis on one page
Commercial heating and cooling services
Illustrative
- Why it should payRepeat service contracts in a fragmented market
- Size$5 million to $20 million of revenue
- PlaceSix states in the Southeast
- OwnershipFounder-owned or family-owned
- Great fitMostly commercial customers, a manager below the owner
- AvoidNew-construction installers
Key takeaways
- An investment thesis is a written argument for what to buy, why it should earn a return and what rules a company out.
- Its parts do two jobs: searchable facts set which companies are in scope, and judgments set how good each one is.
- Size changes price and competition, so test a thesis against what companies of that size cost and who else buys them.
- A useful thesis rejects companies. If nearly everything passes, it is too loose.
- Conversations with owners are the real test, and the thesis should change as they teach you.
What a thesis is
A thesis is an argument, not a wish list. It says: this kind of company, bought at this kind of price, should earn a good return for these reasons. A buyer with a thesis can explain in two minutes why one company is interesting, and in one minute why another is not.
It is different from a mandate, which sets the outer limits of what a fund or company is allowed to buy, and from a screen, which is the list of filters used to search. The thesis comes first and the screen is derived from it. A platform and add-on strategy usually has one thesis for the platform and a narrower one for each kind of add-on.
The parts of a thesis
A working thesis answers seven questions. The example is illustrative.
| Part | Question it answers | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Business | What does the company do | Commercial heating and cooling service and maintenance |
| Return | Why should owning it pay | Repeat service contracts, many owners near retirement, a fragmented market |
| Size | How big | $5 million to $20 million of revenue |
| Place | Where | Six states in the Southeast |
| Ownership | Who owns it now | Founder-owned or family-owned |
| Great fit | What does the best one look like | Mostly commercial customers, technicians on staff, a manager below the owner |
| Avoid | What rules a company out | New-construction installers, or one customer above a third of revenue |
From thesis to search criteria
The parts of a thesis do two different jobs. Business, size, place and ownership are facts that can be searched: they decide which companies are in scope. Great fit and avoid are judgments: they decide how good each company in scope is. Mixing the two is the most common mistake. A judgment used as a filter throws out good companies with imperfect data, a problem covered in scoring vs filtering.
Good judgment criteria are things that can be seen from outside before a conversation, such as the mix of customers, or asked about in the first call, such as revenue quality and concentration. From thesis to target list walks through the next step.
Test the thesis against price, buyers and supply
Price. Size changes what a company costs. GF Data reported average multiples for platform buyouts in the first nine months of 2025 of 5.9 times EBITDA for companies with an enterprise value of $10 million to $25 million, 6.6 times at $25 million to $50 million, 8.7 times at $50 million to $100 million and 10.0 times at $100 million to $250 million. A thesis built on buying smaller companies and combining them rests on that gap. See valuation multiples.
Average EBITDA multiples for platform buyouts, by size
- $10M to $25M5.9x
- $25M to $50M6.6x
- $50M to $100M8.7x
- $100M to $250M10.0x
Buyers. Size also sets the competition. In the IBBA and M&A Source Market Pulse survey for the second quarter of 2026, 47% of buyers of companies valued from $5 million to $50 million were private equity firms and 35% were strategic buyers, while 49% of buyers of companies under $500,000 were first-time buyers.
Supply. A thesis needs enough companies to search. Industry fragmentation shows how to check.
Revise it as you learn
The first twenty conversations test a thesis better than any desk research. Record why each company was kept or passed over. When the same reason for passing appears again and again, it belongs in the thesis. When owners describe their business in different words from yours, change your search words to theirs.
How Equitle helps
In Equitle, a thesis is written in plain words and becomes a scored list. The search you describe sets which companies are in scope, your description of a great fit sets each company's fit score, and the companies you keep or cut teach Hawk your judgment for the next run.
Key terms
Sources
- GF Data (2026). The Size Premium Returns to 2.8x (January 27, 2026), based on the GF Data Q3 2025 M&A Report: average EBITDA multiples for platform buyouts by enterprise value. View source
- IBBA and M&A Source (2026). Market Pulse Report, second quarter 2026, executive summary (survey conducted July 1 to 15, 2026): offers per deal, time to close, buyer types, seller motivations and exit planning. Read in the copy distributed by a member firm. View source
Common questions
How long should an investment thesis be?
One page is enough. If the argument cannot be made in a page, it is usually not yet clear. Supporting research can be as long as it needs to be, but the thesis itself should be short enough for a whole team to repeat.
What is the difference between an investment thesis and investment criteria?
Criteria are the measurable part of a thesis: industry, size, place, ownership. The thesis also includes the reasoning, which is why a company that meets every criterion can still be a poor fit.
How many theses should a team run at once?
As many as it can work properly. Each thesis needs its own list, its own message to owners and enough conversations to learn from, so a few well-worked theses usually teach more than many thin ones.
Does a corporate development team need a thesis?
Yes. The return usually comes from what the acquired company adds to the existing business, such as a new region, product or customer group. The thesis states that reason and the kind of company that provides it.
