Lesson 4 of 6 · Who sells and why
Industry fragmentation
6 min read · Updated Nov 16, 2026
The short answer
A fragmented industry is one where many operators each hold a small share and no firm dominates, which gives an acquirer many founder- and family-owned companies to buy and room to build scale. You measure it with a concentration ratio, the share of revenue held by the largest firms, or with the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, the sum of the squares of every firm's market share.
By the end of this lesson you will be able to:
- Explain why acquirers look for fragmented industries
- Calculate a concentration ratio and a Herfindahl-Hirschman Index
- Read Census concentration data and know its limits
Share of industry revenue held by the four largest firms, 2022
- General automotive repair2.5%
- Offices of dentists3.9%
- Plumbing, heating and air-conditioning contractors4.7%
- Landscaping services7.4%
- Exterminating and pest control services31.1%
- Solid waste collection45.8%
- Passenger car rental89.6%
Key takeaways
- Fragmented means many firms and small shares: in the 2022 Economic Census the four largest landscaping firms held 7.4% of industry revenue.
- The HHI is the sum of the squares of market shares. It reaches 10,000 in a market with a single firm.
- The 2023 Merger Guidelines call a market with an HHI greater than 1,800 highly concentrated.
- National industry data is not a market. A fragmented industry can be concentrated in one city.
What fragmentation means
An industry is fragmented when it has many operators and none of them holds much of the market. The Census Bureau publishes how much of each industry's revenue the largest firms hold. In the 2022 Economic Census, landscaping services had 114,570 firms with payroll, and the four largest held 7.4% of revenue. The 50 largest held 15.5%.
Compare passenger car rental: 2,190 firms, with the four largest holding 89.6%. The first industry is fragmented. The second is concentrated.
Why acquirers look for it
- There are many companies to buy, most of them founder- and family-owned, and many of their owners are 55 or older.
- No dominant firm outbids everyone, so a new entrant can build a position.
- One larger company can be assembled from several smaller ones: a platform and its add-ons. See platform vs add-on acquisitions. Private equity firms and holding companies both build this way.
- Larger companies tend to sell for higher valuation multiples than smaller ones, which is part of the case for combining them.
Two ways to measure it
Concentration ratio. Add up the market shares of the largest firms. The top-four share, often written CR4, is the most common. It is easy to read, but it ignores how share is split among those four and among everyone below them.
Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI). The U.S. Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission define it in their 2023 Merger Guidelines as "the sum of the squares of the market shares." It is small when there are many small firms and reaches 10,000 in a market with a single firm. Under those guidelines, markets with an HHI greater than 1,800 are highly concentrated, and a change of more than 100 points is a significant increase.
Worked example: a five-firm market
Suppose a regional market has five firms with shares of 40%, 25%, 15%, 12% and 8%. Square each share and add the results.
Worked example
HHI for five firms
- 40 squared1,600
- 25 squared625
- 15 squared225
- 12 squared144
- 8 squared64
- HHI2,658
- Top-four share (CR4)92%
Made-up shares. 2,658 is above 1,800, so this market is highly concentrated. If the two smallest firms merged, the HHI would rise by 2 x 12 x 8 = 192 points, to 2,850.
Now picture 100 firms with 1% each. The HHI is 100. That is what a fragmented market looks like in this measure.
Limits of the measure
Census figures describe a national industry code, not a market. A landscaping company competes within driving distance, so an industry that is fragmented nationally can have one dominant operator in a given city. The guidelines apply the HHI to a defined relevant market, which is narrower than an industry code. Use national data to choose where to look, then count competitors in the places you would buy.
How Equitle helps
Equitle's market research sizes an industry, shows how fragmented it is and reads every industry on the same factors, so you can compare industries before you commit to one. The research runs on Equitle's side, so you are not pulling tables into a spreadsheet by hand, and the comparison is waiting when you come back.
Key terms
Sources
- U.S. Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission (2023). 2023 Merger Guidelines, issued December 18, 2023, Guideline 1. Source of the definition of the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, the 1,800 threshold for a highly concentrated market and the 100-point change. View source
- U.S. Census Bureau (2022). 2022 Economic Census, table EC2200SIZECONCEN, "Selected Sectors: Concentration of Largest Firms for the U.S.: 2022". Covers firms with payroll. Source of the firm counts and of the share of revenue held by the 4 and 50 largest firms in each industry. View source
Common questions
What is a fragmented industry?
An industry with many operators where no firm holds a large share. In the 2022 Economic Census, the four largest general automotive repair firms held 2.5% of industry revenue.
How do you calculate the HHI?
Square each firm's market share, expressed as a percentage, and add the results. Five firms with 40%, 25%, 15%, 12% and 8% give 1,600 + 625 + 225 + 144 + 64 = 2,658.
What HHI counts as highly concentrated?
The 2023 Merger Guidelines from the Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission say markets with an HHI greater than 1,800 are highly concentrated, and a change of more than 100 points is a significant increase.
Why do private equity firms like fragmented industries?
Fragmented industries offer many founder- and family-owned companies to acquire and no dominant competitor, so a buyer can start with a platform company and add smaller ones to it.
