EquitleEducationTry for free

Lesson 8 of 9 · How a deal gets done

Asset sale vs stock sale

8 min read · Updated Nov 16, 2026

The short answer

In an asset sale the buyer purchases chosen assets and assumes chosen liabilities of a business, while in a stock sale the buyer purchases the owner's shares and takes the whole company with its history. The choice is driven by tax, which often pulls buyer and seller in opposite directions, and by which liabilities the buyer is willing to inherit.

By the end of this lesson you will be able to:

  • Describe what transfers in an asset sale and in a stock sale
  • Explain why buyers and sellers often want opposite structures
  • Outline how the price is allocated on Form 8594 and what a section 338(h)(10) election does

Asset sale and stock sale side by side

Asset sale

The buyer picks what it takes

  • Named assets and liabilities move
  • The seller keeps the legal entity
  • Contracts are assigned one by one
  • The price is allocated across asset classes
  • Often preferred by buyers

Stock sale

The buyer takes the company whole

  • Shares or membership interests move
  • The entity and its history stay intact
  • Contracts and licenses stay in place
  • All liabilities come with it
  • Often preferred by sellers
The business is the same. What changes is the legal thing being bought, and with it the tax result and the liabilities that follow the buyer.

Key takeaways

  • In an asset sale the buyer takes named assets and liabilities. In a stock sale it takes the entity with everything in it.
  • The IRS treats a sale of a business as a sale of each asset, with gain or loss figured asset by asset.
  • Buyers often prefer assets, for the new tax basis and the liabilities left behind. Sellers often prefer stock.
  • In an asset sale both sides generally file Form 8594 and allocate the price across seven classes, with the remainder to goodwill.
  • A section 338(h)(10) election can give a stock purchase the tax result of an asset purchase in limited cases.

Two ways to buy the same business

A business can change hands in two legal forms. In an asset sale the buyer, usually through a new company, purchases named assets such as equipment, inventory, customer contracts and goodwill, and takes on only the liabilities it agrees to. The seller keeps the legal entity and whatever was left out.

In a stock sale the buyer purchases the owner's shares, or the membership interests of a limited liability company. The entity itself does not change: it keeps its contracts, employees, licenses, tax history and liabilities, known and unknown. Only its owner is different.

What transfers

ItemAsset saleStock sale
LiabilitiesOnly those the buyer assumes, with exceptions set by lawAll of them, including ones nobody knows about yet
Contracts and licensesEach is assigned, which can need the other party's consentThey stay with the entity, unless a change-of-control clause applies
EmployeesRehired by the buyer's companyStill employed by the same entity
Tax basis of the assetsSet by the price paid, as allocatedUnchanged, unless a tax election applies

How tax drives the choice

IRS guidance says a lump-sum sale of a trade or business is "considered a sale of each individual asset rather than of a single asset", and the gain or loss on each asset is figured separately. Capital assets produce capital gain or loss. Inventory produces ordinary income or loss. A sale of corporate stock is simpler: on the same page the IRS says that when you sell stock certificates "you usually realize capital gain or loss".

That creates a tension. A buyer often prefers an asset sale, because its tax basis in what it bought is set by the price it paid and because it can leave liabilities behind. A seller often prefers a stock sale: the gain is usually capital gain, and the liabilities leave with the company. Depending on how the selling company is taxed, an asset sale can also be taxed twice, once in the company and again when the proceeds reach its owners.

Allocating the price

In an asset sale the price has to be divided among the assets, because each kind is taxed differently for both sides. The IRS requires the buyer and the seller to use the residual method, and both generally report the result on Form 8594, Asset Acquisition Statement Under Section 1060, attached to their income tax returns for the year of the sale. The price fills the classes in order, and whatever is left over lands in the last class.

ClassWhat it holds
ICash and general deposit accounts, such as checking and savings accounts
IIActively traded personal property, such as publicly traded stock
IIIAssets marked to market at least annually, and debt instruments including accounts receivable
IVStock in trade and inventory
VAll other assets, generally including furniture, buildings, land, vehicles and equipment
VISection 197 intangibles except goodwill and going concern value, such as licenses and trade names
VIIGoodwill and going concern value

The allocation is negotiated, because a dollar moved from one class to another changes each side's tax. Both sides file the same form, so the allocation is usually settled in the purchase agreement.

The section 338(h)(10) election

Sometimes a deal has to be a stock sale, for example because licenses or contracts cannot be assigned, but the buyer still wants the tax result of an asset purchase. The tax code allows this in limited cases. According to the IRS instructions for Form 8023, a qualified stock purchase is one in which a corporation buys at least 80% of the voting power and value of another corporation's stock within a 12-month acquisition period. With a section 338 election, the target is treated as having sold all of its assets on the acquisition date.

The section 338(h)(10) version is a joint election by the purchasing corporation and the seller. It is available only when the target is bought from a selling consolidated group, a selling affiliate or the shareholders of an S corporation. The form is due by the 15th day of the ninth month after the acquisition date. Because the election changes the seller's tax bill, it is negotiated along with the price.

How buyers and sellers choose

  • Liabilities. A buyer worried about past conduct, such as unpaid taxes or product claims, leans toward assets.
  • Contracts and licenses. A company whose value sits in permits or contracts that cannot be assigned leans toward stock.
  • Financing. SBA rules effective October 1, 2026 allow 7(a) loan proceeds to fund a change of ownership through either a stock purchase or an asset purchase.

Structure belongs in the letter of intent, because it changes what the price is worth to each side. Due diligence then tests the liabilities the structure leaves with the buyer.

How Equitle helps

Deal structure is decided by you, the owner and your tax and legal advisors, and Equitle has no part in it. Its part comes earlier: finding companies that fit your thesis, identifying and researching the owner and starting the conversation in which structure eventually comes up.

Key terms

Sources

  1. Internal Revenue Service (2021). Instructions for Form 8594, Asset Acquisition Statement Under Section 1060 (revised November 2021): who files, the seven asset classes and the residual method of allocating the price. View source
  2. Internal Revenue Service (2026). Sale of a business (page last reviewed or updated February 10, 2026): a sale of a business is treated as a sale of each asset, how the gain on each is characterized, and the treatment of a sale of corporate stock. View source
  3. Internal Revenue Service (2023). Instructions for Form 8023, Elections Under Section 338 for Corporations Making Qualified Stock Purchases (revised October 2023): the qualified stock purchase test, the section 338(h)(10) election and the filing deadline. View source
  4. U.S. Small Business Administration (2026). SOP 50 10 8.1, Lender and Development Company Loan Programs, effective October 1, 2026: change of ownership rules for 7(a) loans, including when a quality of earnings report is required and what it must contain. View source

Common questions

Is an asset sale or a stock sale better for the buyer?

Buyers often prefer an asset sale, because the tax basis of the assets is set by the price paid and unwanted liabilities can be left with the seller. A stock sale can still be the better choice when contracts or licenses cannot be transferred. This is general information, not tax or legal advice.

Why do sellers often prefer a stock sale?

Because the IRS says a sale of stock usually produces capital gain or loss, while an asset sale is taxed asset by asset and some of the gain can be ordinary income. A stock sale also passes the company's liabilities to the buyer.

What is Form 8594?

It is the IRS form on which the buyer and the seller of a business each report how the purchase price was allocated across seven classes of assets. Both generally attach it to their income tax returns for the year of the sale.

Can a limited liability company be sold in a stock sale?

An LLC has membership interests, not stock. Selling those interests is the equivalent deal in legal terms, but its tax treatment depends on how the LLC is taxed, so ask a tax advisor before assuming it works like a stock sale.